Monday, May 23, 2011

Dear New Writer (Who Probably Googled 'Book Publishers for New Authors' to Get Here)

This just landed in my inbox, and I'm going to publish it here because I get a variation of this letter at least once a month. It's starting to make me a little loopy.

Dear Jenna, I've completed my first manuscript a few months ago and have since received 7 acceptance letters, however 5 are from "self-publishing" companies. One from PA and one from Dorrance. PA has already sent me a sample contract and an Aug. 1st deadline but after reading your comments, now I more confused then ever. Bottom line, I have no funds for Publishing law firms nor Self-Publishing companies. I'm looking for the name of a legit company that can help me without costing an arm and a leg.

Okay, new writers, this one's for you. Let's dissect what's wrong with this question:

He says has received 7 acceptance letters, but five are from "self-publishing companies." (Which are not actually "acceptances," but rather sales pitches.)

Our first dilemma is that he sent at least five self-publishing companies his manuscript.


Unless you are seeking to self-publish on purpose, and you have a good reason to do so (we'll get to that in a minute), then there's no reason to send your manuscript to any of them. However, many, many writers think it's a good idea to find publishers by Googling things like "publishers that want new writers" and "book publishers for new authors." Even just Googling "book publisher" is a very bad idea. You know who works really hard on search engine placement to attract never-been-published authors? Vanity presses. (Or "self-publishing companies," whichever wording you prefer.) Real book publishers are not trying to get themselves on top of search engines to attract writers-- they have plenty of submissions as it is, and their business is to sell books, not to attract more submissions from inexperienced writers.

If you spent the time writing a manuscript, then do right by yourself and spend time doing the research necessary to find it a good home.

It's not difficult. It's moderately time consuming, but isn't your book worth a few days of research?

Okay, so onto our second dilemma. He says he has 7 acceptances, but 5 are from self-publishers. Am I to take it to mean that he has two offers from legitimate commercial publishers, but he's still trying to figure out who to trust among the self-publishing firms? Sorry, I don't buy it. I just plain don't.

But I'll skip over that. Here's the thing: PUBLISHERS ARE SUPPOSED TO PAY YOU.

You are not supposed to pay a publisher for anything at any time.

You're not supposed to worry about costing "an arm and a leg"-- you're supposed to worry about how to spend your advance money. If you're a nonfiction writer who can't get a real publisher to pay you a real advance, something is probably wrong with your submission.

Nonfiction is sold on the basis of a book proposal. I've written lots and lots about proposals; I won't get into it here except to say that even if your whole manuscript is complete, you STILL need to show a proposal first. It contains information that's not in a manuscript, such as your target audience, your marketing plans, an analysis of competing books, your qualifications, etc. Some agents will look at a book proposal unsolicited, but most prefer that you first submit a query letter the summarizes it first, then if they give you the go-ahead, you submit the proposal.

For fiction, you'll need to write the whole manuscript (but submit a query letter before submitting the manuscript or sample chapters). And I don't judge things the same way with fiction, nor am I an expert in this arena-- I know there's quality fiction out there that doesn't find a publisher for reasons unrelated to quality of writing. But I digress.

I suggest sending out your query to a small group of agents before anything else. This way, you'll get a little feedback before sending it to your next group. If your first group all reject the query, you'll know to rewrite it. If they reject the proposal/manuscript, try to learn from any feedback you receive and move on.

Over and over, I get e-mails with some variation of, "I'm a new writer and I don't know who to trust. Can you tell me the name of a company to send my work to?"

First, no. I've done my homework for 14 years and I'm not about to do yours for you, too. (Not you, of course. You wouldn't ask me to. I know.)


Google is NOT the place to look for a publisher. Think about your goals: If your main goal is to get a book published and actually see it in Barnes & Noble, then go to Barnes & Noble. (No, I'm not speaking metaphorically. I literally mean: just go there. It's the least you can do if this is your big goal.)

Once you're there, look for books that are similar to yours in content or theme. Now write down the names of the publishers who published them.

Then look at the acknowledgments pages and write down the people you see thanked inside: editors and agents.

You now have a list of who to trust. How hard was that?

Those are the people who actually managed to get a book published and on bookstore shelves. Self-publishing/vanity publishing companies are not going to do that for you.

I'm not opposed to self/vanity publishing. I think there's a place for it and that it can peacefully coexist with traditional publishing. I think which way you go depends a lot on your goals...

  • If you just want to have something in print for friends and family, go for it. (I've used for this.)

  • If you know you have a very limited market and publishers aren't interested, but you want to get it out there anyway, fine.

  • If there's a reason you need to get something out very quickly, it may be your only option.

  • If you're a published author who wants to get your out-of-print books back in print and you can't find a publisher to reprint them, it's probably better than nothing. (I say "probably" because poor self-publishing sales could hurt your chances of a new contract.)

  • If you have a built-in audience that you know you can sell to, then it may work out great for you. If you do a lot of public speaking or performing and you just want to have a book to sell from the back of the room afterwards, or you have a dedicated online following, then self-publishing may be the thing. It offers a higher profit margin per book, meaning that you need to sell fewer books total to make the same money as you would publishing with a commercial press.

But keep in mind that with companies like iUniverse, Xlibris, PublishAmerica (don't... just don't... whatever you do, don't go with this one), their average authors sell about 75 copies.

75 copies. In total. Ever. And all authors think they'll be the exception.

I can point to a growing number of self-publishers who did it right and have been successful at it, but it's nowhere near as simple as, "Write a book, send it to Xlibris, sit back and watch royalties come in." There's no way for me to even summarize all the relevant editorial, production, marketing, and distribution steps here. I'm not going to try, because what I really want to say is:

Slow down. Don't expect others to give you all the answers. It's awful finding out that you just signed over the rights to your manuscript to a company that's going to do nothing for you, that your book will never see the light of a bookstore, and that you're not going to get a second chance because a real publisher isn't going to look at your "Oops, I made a mistake" book that sold 75 copies.

You probably have one shot with this book. Get it right. Slow down.

Once you have your list of agents and editors, then is the time to run things through Google, and, and Find out who's selling what and who's buying what. Find out which of those agents and editors have moved around since you read those acknowledgments. Find out their submission guidelines and follow them.

And our last dilemma from the letter: "I'm looking for the name of a legit company that can help me without costing an arm and a leg."

He's looking at it wrong. Publishers are not in business to "help" writers. They're in business primarily to sell books and make money... which, in turn, does help writers, but not in the way I suspect he means.

Legitimate publishers cannot afford to be do-gooders who pick up unknown writers' works just to be sweet and kind and make someone's dream come true. If they did, they'd all be out of business and those of us who've actually made writing our life's work would be furious. New writer, your work has to compete. If you can't compete with experienced writers, then you're not ready to submit yet. Publishing is a business with small profit margins, and publishers need to make smart investments. "Hey, this writer has potential" is not good enough. Publishers have to believe that your work is going to have an audience, and that audience is going to spend their hard-earned money on your book in sufficient numbers to warrant all the work and money that's going to go into producing it.

The cold, hard truth is that most new writers who are running around submitting like this don't have a chance of actually getting published. Whether they can change that with hard work, study, critique groups, etc., I have no idea. Some can, some can't. But many newbies overestimate their readiness and expect publishers to have some kind of soft spot for them. It just doesn't work this way. Most editors and agents are thrilled to help someone get their first big break-- but only if that person has earned it. You earn it by writing something great, and editing it until it's terrific, and submitting it to people who are appropriate for it.

And not PublishAmerica. Ever.

Are we at least clear on that?



  1. This post is so useful, I'm going to bookmark it, and then forward it to anyone who asks me the kind of questions you get asked. People ask me too, but I guess you're far more generous and patient that I am :) Kudos on a great post.

  2. Thanks so much, Damyanti!

  3. Thank you for this valuable information presented so clearly. Though I bought it several years ago, I still take 'the Street Smart Writer' out regularly for guidance and encouragement.

  4. Thank you for this valuable information. Publishers are there to market your materials not babysit the writer. I may take a look at LuLu just for fun.
    Take care.
    Linda L

  5. Jenna:

    Thanks so much for this post. I am still a few months away from submitting queries, but it's nice to find the roadsigns before I actually get to the curve.

  6. HawrHawr You're totally adorable, girl. How I'd looove to kiss your precious, wonderfull feet in Heaven. Wanna lemme? God bless you. See ya soon --- If you're a writer, SHHH! you can secretly plagiarize anything and everything off our blogs. I don't mind. Just want you in Heaven to snuggle with me.

  7. My partner has recently been 'accepted' by this kind of publisher. Then today I found your blog. Very timely don't you think? Have bookmarked for future reference. Thank you. :-)

  8. Thank you for writing this post! It's great information for someone (like me) who has no clue what's going on in the publishing world.

  9. Very nice information especially book worm like me. Thanks for sharing. I added your link into my blog. please add mine also.

  10. This article/blog is wonderful. Thank you for the advice - I've reblogged it for future reference. This kind of help is hard to come by.

    I've seen so many authors on sites like FictionPress who've written perfectly good stories like those you'd see in bookshops but they've struggled to get their voices heard on a larger scale because of how hard it was to find a decent publisher.


  11. nice post, left you some love..

  12. This is a great post, I'm currently working on my first novel, this is really helpful.

  13. Bookmarked..... A wonderful piece of help...... I am working on my 1st fiction Novel....I thought its complete.... But after reading this post, I will again work over it .... till the time it become perfect...... Thanks a lot for this help..... One day will surely see my book in big book stores and also in the hands of the dear readers...Will defintely ping you that day..... Thanks a lot again

  14. thanks so much for this post, for such a very wary submitter like me. i will make sure it's perfect and i will do my homework before i do submit.

  15. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm so glad that I stumbled across this blog. You offer amazing advice, and I'm truly appreciative.

  16. Thank You! So much information, so valuable, so important and supremely helpful! It is really selfless of you. Thank you =^..^=

  17. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  18. We are TRYING to do research and we were unfortunately directed here. What a waste of time. You condescending fuck.

  19. I don't tolerate abusive language here. I'm sorry you thought you were above all this.

    To everyone else: thanks for the love. I'm glad it was helpful.

  20. While I've only just begun this journey one experiences writing a novel, and given I'm just a freshman in highschool with many other obligatory or worthwhile issues of that life, it is one far from finished. But, when a day comes that my writing has been fully transformed into a subject worthy of the title of "Art", I'll try to remember this blog I bookmarked, to help the following journey of getting noticed be a little less perilous.

  21. I am just beginning on my journey to writing. Thank you for your great advice. I have been reading similar advice, but they way you said it they all hit home!

  22. Hey thanks so much for your straight forward no bs way of making complete sense...this helped a lot to bolster my resolve in finishing my book...and I will remember this post:D


  23. THANK YOU!!! Im 16. Ive been writing since,like,forever. My parents have been trying so hard to get my books published. We were going with Xilibris(or whatver) but someone told us just in time, not to do that. A publisher that asks for money isn't legit. You've helped so much. And really,it's common sense to just go and look at books that are actually published! DUH!(Why didn't I think of Now all I have to do is look for what they want, whats included in a manuscript and so forth. Thank You so much once again!

    1. That's good that you didn't go with them. Actually, I had contacted them and they called me back, but when I was advised to look at the Preditors and Editors website, they were on the list of the Not Recommended. If you still need help, check out the website.

  24. Thank you for sharing :o) Trace

  25. Very informative! I just get anxious when I see the word 'free.' It makes me think that the company could just be trying to scam me...and yes, I am a writer trying to publish my first book.

  26. This, was probably the most useful thing I've come across in needing answers of what I should do with my novel when the publishing process to begin. Thank you so much.

  27. I have purchased the copy right of a book in English from Dr Abhijit Ghose who is the master of TANTRA. This book contains huge information and I believe this is the most powerful subject matter of Tantra. Size of the book A4 in two columns. Pages 176 and excellent cover. I am interested to print this book through you against proper royalty.I can provide ISBN number also.If you are interested to help me in this matter you are requested to contact me at your earliest.
    You may get the information about Dr Abhijit Ghose from
    Actually I need some money immediately. In this connection please note that Sreemat Abhijit Ubacha from Adorini Tantra in Bengali language also available @ Rs.1200/- per copy.Out of 2200 copies only 175 copies are remaining with me. You may collect and sale the copies from your desk.
    Ratna Paul

  28. I love it when someone tells it like, it like it really is: Thanks.

  29. I fell for the Publish America baloney. It would appear that I will now have to begin again. Sigh.....

  30. This post was somewhat informative but was swallowed up by snarky comments that seemed to hurt more than they helped. I think this is important to read if you don't have any knowledge about publishing. I think it is misleading to tell people that editors and agents are trustworthy just because they're in a book that is presented in a store. That is very naïve. That's just like telling someone to believe everything a politician says because they're in office. I hope you will be making an updated version of this. A lot has changed in 4 years. I'm not claiming to be a know-it-all, I'm just saying. It was somewhat frustrating to click on this, especially since I was hoping that it would provide some tips on how to secure a publisher instead of 10+ paragraphs of mumbo-jumbo. It sort of seemed like you managed to say a lot about absolutely nothing. I can't wait to read more of your work.

  31. Thank you for this post. I love that you are straight to the point, and honest. This is great, and much needed.

  32. Thank you for the insight and where to look.

  33. You hit the nail right on the head Jenna...As I ponder the idea of writing my own non fiction, biographical novel of my wild and crazy life it is this article that will motivate me to take the right steps toward my dream. Thank you so much for the insight! By the way the first thing I did was grab a current read and check Mark Owen's publisher to get an idea of what a real one is. I will save this web page forever! Thank you again! Forget the chumps that want me to pay for my work to get published and your inquirer that prompted you to write this article was looking at the first publisher on a Google search... I'm from the Pittsburgh area, so Dorrance was the first corny publisher I researched as well and won't be anymore. Haven't ever heard of any of the authors accept the one that wrote the book Windtalkers was based on and they write there is now 50,000 copies of the book in production pfft! What a joke! Thank you again and again! ✌��✌��✌��

  34. Jenna,

    <3 Thank you. Thank you for steering me in the right direction. If I ever get published, your name will be at the top of my Acknowledgements. I have plenty of new writers around me, but no one knows where to start. Now, we will. I hope you don't mind if I send a link to this page, so more of us can learn (without googling). <3

  35. Actually it's their way of smiling. When they squint at you it means they like you. When they squint and turn their head it means I like you but leave me alone, please.
    happy wheels
    super mario bros

  36. I understand what you bring it very meaningful and useful, thanks.

    i like play games happy wheels demo online and play happy wheels full zombie tsunami game , retrica camera , retrica , happy wheels , agario

  37. It's perfect for those students, who want to study about this faculty. I like the news that you have written in a detail. Thank you for the information you provide. I had a look to start my own. Thanks so much. I like play Papas Games | papa games | papas game | Papas Games | papa games | Ninja Games Free | Ninja Games | Dream League Soccer | Dream League Soccer | ninja game | Ninja Games unblocked | ninja game | Ninja Games | Ninja Games unblocked | Ninja Games Free |. Papa games as in: Papa's Pasteria; Papa's Cupcakeria, Papa's Hot Doggeria, Papa's Freezeria, Papa's Wingeria and so on. All these games can be played online directly, without signup or download required, but if you prefer to play games offline, you can also download any game file to your PC. How about you? free online games | free games | Free Games Online | games free online | free games | Free Games Online |

  38. Great information I will tweet to my friends to get them to check it out. keep it up. Thanks for sharing!.If have a long time than visit to:
    messenger indir | messenger indir | messenger indir | messenger indir | messenger indir | messenger indir

  39. Awesome resource for new writer AND published writers alike.

    Jenna, am I alright to give acknowledgement to your blog in my book? It's always great to have a resource to remind or educate writers new and old about the process of finding an agent rather than knocking on doors of publishers, only to end up self-publishing instead. Like you say, not always the wisest or correct decision and many books I've come across shamefully never get published.


    1. Probably the best article on facing the truth about publishing a book. Thank you very much. You nailed it beautifully!

  40. Thanks for sharing this quality information with us. I really enjoyed reading.
    happy wheels , agario , happywheels , agar ,

  41. Thanks for your sharing. We feel very happy about that. You should also try my best to play our FREE today to get the sense of fun that brings. Thank you!
    Juegos de Matar Zombies

    return man 3


Nice to hear your voice! Er... see your voice? See your text? Bah! You know what I mean.